The Freemium vs. Free Trial Dilemma: Choosing the Right Customer Acquisition Model

August 4, 2023
Product & Growth

Freemium is like a Samurai sword: unless you’re a master at using it, you can cut your arm off." - Rob Walling. Ah, the age-old question: 

Should I go with a free trial or jump on the freemium bandwagon? 🤔 It's a decision that can make or break your SaaS business. But hold your horses! Before you start Googling and asking other SaaS founders for advice, let's take a step back. The truth is, what works for others may not work for you. 

Your business is unique, just like you! 😉 To help you make this crucial decision, we present the magnificent MOAT framework, designed to guide you towards the right choice. 🏰 Let's dive in!

 1️⃣ Market Strategy: Dominant, Differentiated, or Disruptive? 🌟

Dominant Growth Strategy
If you want to be the undisputed market leader, charging significantly less while offering a superior product, you're aiming for dominance. Think Netflix, Uber, and Shopify. 
Ask yourself:

- Is your target market large enough to support a freemium model? 
- Can your product outshine competitors in solving a specific job? 

If yes, both freemium and free trial models can be your secret weapons, keeping costs low while ensuring your market share remains untouchable. 📈💪 

Differentiated Growth Strategy
Now, if your focus is on delivering a specialized, high-cost solution to underserved customers, you're on the path of differentiation. Free trials and demos work well here, but creating a freemium experience can be challenging. 

Remember, your competitive edge lies in how you solve your customers' problems. So, make that "Aha!" moment count during the trial! 💡💼

Disruptive SaaS Growth Strategy
Being a disruptor means offering a simpler product that solves specific pain points for over-served customers. Companies like Canva, Google Docs, Udacity, and Wave have mastered this approach. 

To check if it suits you, consider these questions:

- Is your market filled with over-served customers? 
- Can your resources support a freemium model? 
- And most importantly, can your user onboarding be self-service?

If so, freemium can be your mighty weapon to attract prospects away from existing solutions. 🔥✨

Make a decision on your growth strategy
Now that you've analyzed your market strategy, it's decision time! Are you dominant, differentiated, or disruptive? Choose the path that aligns with your goals and vision. This will make it much easier to determine whether a free trial, freemium, or demo model is the way to go for your business. 🚀🔓

Courtesy: Product Led

 2️⃣  Ocean Conditions: Red or Blue? 🌊

Are you swimming in a red ocean or cruising in a blue ocean? In a red ocean, you're competing fiercely for existing demand, where products become commodities and competition turns bloody. But in a blue ocean, you have the opportunity to tap into untapped market space and create demand.

Now, here's the catch: If you're in a blue ocean, launching a no-touch, self-service model right away might leave your potential customers scratching their heads. Education is key! 

On the other hand, if you're in a red ocean, a self-service model can widen your funnel, decrease your customer acquisition cost (CAC), and help you expand globally. So, assess the ocean conditions before you set sail! ⛵️🦈

3️⃣ Audience: Top-Down or Bottom-Up? 🤝

Ah, the makers and shakers of the world! Makers are the doers, the ones who try before they buy and want to understand how a product can solve their problems. 

Shakers, conversely, are the decision-makers, often high-level management with the power to "shake" the business. Most companies target the shakers because they hold the purse strings. But here's the thing: If your target audience is the shakers, a top-down marketing approach is crucial. They need to see the big picture of how your software tool can grow their business. They might not be the end-users, but they hold the power to make the purchasing decisions.

However, if your target audience is the makers, the individual contributors executing on the business strategy, leading with a free trial or freemium model can work wonders. Makers want to experience the core value of your product and be convinced of its benefits. They can become your advocates and make a compelling case to the Shakers. It's a bottom-up approach that can gain traction and help you build a loyal user base. So, align your marketing approach with your target audience and watch the magic unfold! ✨👥

Combining Bottom-Up and Top-Down
Can you have the best of both worlds? Absolutely! 

Take Vidyard, for example. They launched a freemium product called GoVideo while maintaining their top-down marketing approach. It's about finding the right balance that suits your business and audience. So, if you target the shakers, a free trial or freemium model might not be the ideal starting point. But as you grow and expand, you can consider launching a self-service arm to cater to the makers. Adapt and evolve, my friend! 🌱💼


⚖️The Decision is Yours! ⚖️

There you have it—the MOAT framework to help you navigate the freemium vs. free trial conundrum. Remember, there's no one-size-fits-all solution. Analyze your market strategy, assess the ocean conditions, and understand your target audience. Once you have a clear vision of your growth strategy, choosing between a free trial, freemium, or demo model will become a breeze. So, arm yourself with knowledge, make a strategic decision, and go conquer the SaaS world! 🚀🌐💪

Tool of the Day

With this tool, you can generate replies automatically for posts using AI. It is the easiest way to connect with the community, look clever, funny, professional on social media, appear smarter and grow your audience with 10x less effort. Working for Twitter, LinkedIn & Product Hunt.

Past Newsletters

Consistency in UI Design

February 18, 2023

Data Driven Design

February 6, 2023
320,000+ people have already
signed up, what are you waiting for?
Subscribe Now